New to LiveAuctioneers?

Starr Arms Co. Model 1858 Double Action Army Revolver

Description

Message us to get the video showing the action condition. A Starr Arms Co. Model 1858 Double Action Army revolver, .44 caliber. This percussion firearm features a 6-inch round barrel and smooth walnut grips. The left side of the frame is stamped STARR ARMS CO. NEW YORK. The serial number 20357 is visible on the cylinder, frame, and other major components. The revolver exhibits numerous military inspector markings, including single-letter stamps on various steel parts and a visible inspector cartouche on the left grip. The construction consists of a blued steel frame and cylinder. Barrel length: 6 inches. This item is either black powder or manufactured in or before 1898 (and does not take readily available ammunition), and thus does not require an FFL or background check. We can hand out to you at pickup or ship to the address of your choice. In-house shipping available. Pick up is Saturday, March 29 from 10 am to 4 pm at our gallery in Lancaster, Ohio 43130 or we will provide in-house shipping for this item. We will charge a $5 fee if you want to pick this lot up another day. Once packed up we will send you an invoice for shipping & handling. Shipping questions: shipping@burnsbid.com. Sales tax is collected on this auction. AB277

Buyer's Premium

23%

Starr Arms Co. Model 1858 Double Action Army Revolver

Lot 0010

Estimate $10-$1,000Mar 28, 2026, 11:00 AM EDT

Current Price (6 bids)

Secure

$400

SET YOUR MAX BID

Good Bid

Strong Bid

Competitive Bid

Or select a higher max bid amount

28 bidders are watching this item

Get approved to bid.

LiveAuctioneers Purchase Protection

Vetted auction houses

Secure, online bidding

Returns guaranteed for misrepresented listings

Dedicated support when you need it

Burns March Militaria & Firearms

Mar 28, 2026 11:00 AM EDT

Lancaster, OH, United States

Colt Model 1849 Pocket Revolver: A Colt Model 1849 Pocket Revolver, .31 caliber percussion, featuring a 4-inch octagonal barrel and a five-shot cylinder. The firearm is constructed with a steel frame, barrel, and cylinder,

2 days LeftColt Model 1849 Pocket Revolver

U.S. WWI Remington Mark III 10 Gauge Flare Signal Pistol: A Remington Mark III flare signal pistol manufactured by the Remington Arms - Union Metallic Cartridge Co. in Bridgeport, Connecticut. The pistol features a 9 inch polished chrome barrel, a brass

2 days LeftU.S. WWI Remington Mark III 10 Gauge Flare Signal Pistol

Rogers & Spencer Army Model Percussion Revolver: This Rogers & Spencer Army Model percussion revolver features a 7.5-inch octagonal barrel and is chambered in .44 caliber. The top strap is stamped with the manufacturer mark ROGERS & SPENCER / UTICA

2 days LeftRogers & Spencer Army Model Percussion Revolver

J. Stevens & Co. Tip Up Single Shot Pocket Pistol: A J. Stevens & Co. Tip Up single-shot pocket pistol, also known as the Old Model, chambered in .32 RF. The firearm features a 3.5-inch steel barrel that transitions from an octagonal breech to a

2 days LeftJ. Stevens & Co. Tip Up Single Shot Pocket Pistol

Two Vintage Non-Lethal Pistols Including August Schuler M33 and EM-GE Model 6: This collection features two vintage German non-lethal firearms. The first is an August Schuler M33 gas pistol, constructed with a dark metallic finish and featuring textured grips with an

2 days LeftTwo Vintage Non-Lethal Pistols Including August Schuler M33 and EM-GE Model 6

** Walther P.38 Semi-Automatic Pistol, ac 44 Code: A World War II era Walther P.38 semi-automatic pistol manufactured by Carl Walther Waffenfabrik in 1944. The firearm is chambered in 9mm Parabellum and features a blued steel finish with

2 days Left** Walther P.38 Semi-Automatic Pistol, ac 44 Code

** Astra Model 1916 Semi-Automatic Pistol: This Astra Model 1916 semi-automatic pistol was manufactured by Esperanza y Unceta in Guernica, Spain. Chambered in 7.65mm (.32 ACP), the firearm features a steel slide and frame with checkered

2 days Left** Astra Model 1916 Semi-Automatic Pistol

** French MAS Model 1936-51 Bolt-Action Rifle: A French MAS Model 1936-51 bolt-action rifle manufactured by Manufacture d'Armes de Saint-Etienne (MAS). This firearm is chambered in 7.5 x 54mm and features a matte-finished steel receiver paired

2 days Left** French MAS Model 1936-51 Bolt-Action Rifle

** Underwood M1 Carbine .30 Caliber Semi-Automatic Rifle: An Underwood-manufactured M1 Carbine chambered in .30 M1 featuring an 18-inch barrel and a wooden stock. The receiver is marked U.S. CARBINE CAL .30 M1 and UNDERWOOD above serial number 2774107. The

2 days Left** Underwood M1 Carbine .30 Caliber Semi-Automatic Rifle

** U.S. Model of 1917 Eddystone Bolt-Action Rifle: A U.S. Model of 1917 bolt-action service rifle manufactured by Remington at the Eddystone plant. The rifle features a full-length walnut stock with a polished reddish-brown finish and is equipped

2 days Left** U.S. Model of 1917 Eddystone Bolt-Action Rifle

** Soviet Mosin-Nagant Model 1944 Carbine and Accessories: This lot features a Soviet Mosin-Nagant Model 1944 (M44) bolt-action carbine chambered in 7.62x54R. The barrel shank is dated 1944 and bears the Izhevsk arsenal mark of a triangle with an internal

2 days Left** Soviet Mosin-Nagant Model 1944 Carbine and Accessories

** Remington Model 1903 Bolt Action Rifle: This Remington Model 1903 bolt-action rifle is chambered in .30-06 Springfield and carries serial number 3246055. The receiver is stamped U.S. REMINGTON MODEL 1903. The firearm features a 24.75-inch

2 days Left** Remington Model 1903 Bolt Action Rifle

Ethan Allen and Co. Sidehammer .22 Rimfire Pocket Revolver: An Ethan Allen and Co. sidehammer pocket revolver, serial number 16619. This firearm features a 2.5-inch octagonal barrel chambered in .22 rimfire. The top of the barrel is stamped with the maker's

2 days LeftEthan Allen and Co. Sidehammer .22 Rimfire Pocket Revolver

National Arms Co. No. 2 .41 Rimfire Derringer Pistol: A National Arms Co. No. 2 Derringer pocket pistol chambered in .41 caliber rimfire. This 19th-century firearm features an engraved metal frame and barrel with decorative scrollwork at the muzzle and

2 days LeftNational Arms Co. No. 2 .41 Rimfire Derringer Pistol

C. Sharps 1859 .22 Caliber Pepperbox Pistol: This C. Sharps Model Pepperbox four-shot pistol features 2.5-inch sliding steel barrels chambered for .22 rimfire. The firearm is constructed with a brass frame and fitted with smooth wood grips. The

2 days LeftC. Sharps 1859 .22 Caliber Pepperbox Pistol

** Merwin Hulbert and Co. Medium Frame Spur Trigger Revolver: A Merwin Hulbert and Co. medium frame spur trigger revolver manufactured by Hopkins and Allen of Norwich, Connecticut. This single action firearm is chambered in .38 centerfire and features a

2 days Left** Merwin Hulbert and Co. Medium Frame Spur Trigger Revolver

** Tula Russian Nagant Model 1895 Revolver: A Russian Nagant Model 1895 revolver manufactured at the Tula Arsenal. This firearm is chambered in 7.62 x 38R and features a 4.5-inch barrel with fixed sights. The left side of the frame is stamped

2 days Left** Tula Russian Nagant Model 1895 Revolver

Smith & Wesson Model 1 1/2 Revolver: Smith & Wesson Model 1 1/2 single-action, top-break revolver chambered in .32 S&W. The firearm features a nickel-plated finish and a five-shot fluted cylinder. It is designed with a spur trigger and

2 days LeftSmith & Wesson Model 1 1/2 Revolver

Belgian Pinfire Revolver: A Belgian pinfire revolver featuring a round barrel and a six-shot cylinder. The firearm is constructed with metal components and fitted with polished hardwood grips. Stamped markings include BREVETE

2 days LeftBelgian Pinfire Revolver

** US World War II Guide Lamp FP-45 Liberator Pistol: A World War II-era FP-45 Liberator single-shot pistol manufactured by the Guide Lamp Division of General Motors. The firearm is constructed from stamped steel with a cast zinc cocking piece and

2 days Left** US World War II Guide Lamp FP-45 Liberator Pistol

Related Items

Belgian Pinfire Revolver: A Belgian pinfire revolver featuring a round barrel and a six-shot cylinder. The firearm is constructed with metal components and fitted with polished hardwood grips. Stamped markings include BREVETE

2 days LeftBelgian Pinfire Revolver

** Tula Russian Nagant Model 1895 Revolver: A Russian Nagant Model 1895 revolver manufactured at the Tula Arsenal. This firearm is chambered in 7.62 x 38R and features a 4.5-inch barrel with fixed sights. The left side of the frame is stamped

2 days Left** Tula Russian Nagant Model 1895 Revolver

SCARCE CIVIL WAR COLT MODEL 4 ROOT REVOLVER.: Cal. 31. S# 1484. Revolver has all the distinguishing features of model 4s; fluted 5-shot cylinder; 3.5" octagonal barrel with 2-line patent & address, cylinder has patent stamped in flute, varnished

Apr 19, 2026SCARCE CIVIL WAR COLT MODEL 4 ROOT REVOLVER.

Colt Model 1849 Pocket Revolver: A Colt Model 1849 Pocket Revolver, .31 caliber percussion, featuring a 4-inch octagonal barrel and a five-shot cylinder. The firearm is constructed with a steel frame, barrel, and cylinder,

2 days LeftColt Model 1849 Pocket Revolver

Starr Single Action Army .44 Caliber Revolver: Made by Starr Arms Company of New York City circa 1864 with about 32,000 made. This revolver has a blued 7-1/2" round .44 caliber rifled barrel with hinged loading lever and blade front sight. Gun has

Apr 18, 2026Starr Single Action Army .44 Caliber Revolver

Smith & Wesson Model 1 1/2 Revolver: Smith & Wesson Model 1 1/2 single-action, top-break revolver chambered in .32 S&W. The firearm features a nickel-plated finish and a five-shot fluted cylinder. It is designed with a spur trigger and

2 days LeftSmith & Wesson Model 1 1/2 Revolver

Colt Model 1847 Walker Revolver, U.S. Mounted Service, Marked “C Company No. 8: This Colt Model 1847 Walker revolver represents one of the most powerful and historically significant handguns of the 19th century. Designed in collaboration between Samuel Colt and Captain Samuel Ham

Apr 06, 2026Colt Model 1847 Walker Revolver, U.S. Mounted Service, Marked “C Company No. 8

Rare Collector 1860 Antique Colt Model 1860 Army .44 Cal Fluted Percussion 7-1/2" Revolver: Manufactured by Colt in 1860. This Army revolver features a 7-1/2" round barrel with silver front blade and rear notched hammer lip sights. Top of the barrel is stamped "-ADDRESS SMAL COLT HARTFORD CT

Apr 18, 2026Rare Collector 1860 Antique Colt Model 1860 Army .44 Cal Fluted Percussion 7-1/2" Revolver

A .35 CALIBRE SIX-SHOT PERCUSSION CONTINENTAL COPY OF A COLT NAVY REVOLVER,: 5inch sighted octagonal barrel, the cylinder with naval engagement scene, the left side of the frame stamped .35 CAL, the right side PATENT SYTEM and with a crown over P, wooden grips, serial no. 1046

Apr 08, 2026A .35 CALIBRE SIX-SHOT PERCUSSION CONTINENTAL COPY OF A COLT NAVY REVOLVER,

CIVIL WAR ERA MODEL 6 COLT 1855 ROOT REVOLVER.: Cal. 31. S# 10534. Standard configuration side hammer Colt Model 6 revolver manufactured 1865, 3.5" 2-stage round barrel, cylinder with stagecoach holdup rolled scene, two-line New York USA barrel add

Apr 19, 2026CIVIL WAR ERA MODEL 6 COLT 1855 ROOT REVOLVER.

Honest 1865 Antique Colt Model 1860 Army .44 Cal Percussion 8" Revolver: Manufactured by Colt in 1865. This Army revolver features an 8" round barrel with silver front blade and rear notched hammer lip sights. Top of the barrel is stamped "ADDRESS COL. SMAL COLT NEW - YORK

Apr 18, 2026Honest 1865 Antique Colt Model 1860 Army .44 Cal Percussion 8" Revolver

Good US Civil War REMINGTON MODEL 1858 REVOLVER: Robust Remington Model 1858 percussion army revolver, a staple sidearm of Union and Confederate forces during the Civil War. Features a six shot octagonal barrel seasoned by battlefield smoke, surface

2 days LeftGood US Civil War REMINGTON MODEL 1858 REVOLVER

TOP